MSG Knickerbockers Corp.
Fair value per share
$55.74
from SEC filings only
- Margin of safety price
- $41.81
- 25% below fair value
- Stress case
- $7.77
- if things go badly
Its filings point to about $55.74 a share, most likely between $21.17 and $73.36.
The short case
In favour
- Sales have grown about 23% a year over the last five years.
- It has been shrinking its share count, so each share owns more.
Against
- This estimate is less than a third of what outside investors' shares were worth on the company's cover page (December 31, 2025): the filings alone probably miss what investors expect (faster growth, margins still changing, or a business that is changing).
- Working capital is unusually low right now (suppliers or customers are funding more than usual), which may not last.
- It burned cash over the last 12 months.
Price check. The filings support about $55.74 a share ($41.81 with a 25% cushion). Compare that with the price in the delayed quote below before reading anything into the points above: a price well above it means the market expects more than the filings show.
Written automatically from the filings, by the same rules for every company. Not a recommendation.
Five areas
9 of 25 checks passedStrong in 0 of 5 areas
GrowthFair · 3 of 5
- Revenue up 5%+ a year over 3 years (passed)
- Revenue up 5%+ a year over 5 years (passed)
- Earnings per share up 5%+ a year over 5 years (no data)
- Revenue up over the last 12 months (passed)
- Earnings per share up over the last 12 months (no data)
ProfitabilityWeak · 0 of 5
- Return on equity of 15%+ (last 12 months) (no data)
- Return on equity of 12%+ (5-year average) (no data)
- Return on invested capital of 10%+ (5-year average) (no data)
- Operating margin of 10%+ (5-year average) (not passed)
- Operating margin holding up (last 12 months vs 5 years) (not passed)
Cash generationWeak · 2 of 5
- Cash earnings positive in almost every year (at most one bad year) (passed)
- Typical year turns 10%+ of revenue into cash (not passed)
- Latest year at or above the typical year (not passed)
- Free cash flow positive (last 12 months) (not passed)
- Revenue larger than 5 years ago (passed)
Balance sheetWeak · 2 of 5
- Debt no larger than equity (not passed)
- Cash and short-term investments exceed debt (not passed)
- Positive shareholders' equity (not passed)
- Debt clearly tagged in the filings (passed)
- Operating margin above zero (last 12 months) (passed)
Shareholder returnsWeak · 2 of 5
- Pays a dividend (passed)
- Dividend paid in each of the last 5 years (not passed)
- Dividend grew over 5 years (no data)
- Pays out 75% or less of earnings (not passed)
- Share count flat or falling over 5 years (passed)
Flags
This estimate is less than a third of what outside investors' shares were worth on the company's cover page (December 31, 2025): the filings alone probably miss what investors expect (faster growth, margins still changing, or a business that is changing).
Working capital is unusually low right now (suppliers or customers are funding more than usual), which may not last.
How we got this number
In a typical year MSGS kept 7% of its revenue as cash after running and maintaining the business (before interest). We assume revenue grows 8.9% a year for five years, then slows to 2.5% by year ten, and discount the cash at 9.3% a year (the 10-year Treasury yield plus 5 points, blended with the cost of its debt). That is worth $55.74 a share today.
Technical details
- Model
- Discounted cash flow on cash earnings
- Cash-earnings margin: typical year (worst / best 3-year stretch)
- 7.2% (3.8% / 9.2%)
- Years used
- 2022–2026
- Revenue growth, years 1–5 (range tested)
- 8.9% (4 to 14%)
- Capital needed per $1 of new revenue
- $0.03 equipment, $-0.17 working capital
- Discount rate
- 9.3%
- Revenue base
- $1.2B (lower of TTM and last FY)
- Debt / cash
- $0.3B / $0.0B
- Value if investors require Treasury + 3 / + 8 points (we use + 5)
- $70.23 / $42.42
- If growth after year 10 keeps today's returns
- $68.74
- Likely range
- 10th–90th percentile of 4,000 runs with different assumptions
- Required return
- 10-year Treasury 5.15% (2026-11-13) + 5%
Ten years of results
Revenue
$1.2B in FY2026, up 11% on the year before
Show as table
| Year | Revenue |
|---|---|
| FY2017 | $1.3B |
| FY2018 | $1.6B |
| FY2019 | $1.6B |
| FY2020 | $603M |
| FY2021 | $416M |
| FY2022 | $821M |
| FY2023 | $887M |
| FY2024 | $1.0B |
| FY2025 | $1.0B |
| FY2026 | $1.2B |
Cash earnings as a share of sales
1.3% of sales in FY2026
Show as table
| Year | Cash earnings as a share of sales |
|---|---|
| FY2017 | – |
| FY2018 | – |
| FY2019 | – |
| FY2020 | – |
| FY2021 | – |
| FY2022 | 10.4% |
| FY2023 | 7.2% |
| FY2024 | 10.2% |
| FY2025 | -0.1% |
| FY2026 | 1.3% |
Dividends per share
$7.00 a share in FY2026
Show as table
| Year | Dividends per share |
|---|---|
| FY2017 | – |
| FY2018 | – |
| FY2019 | – |
| FY2020 | – |
| FY2021 | – |
| FY2022 | – |
| FY2023 | $7.00 |
| FY2024 | $7.00 |
| FY2025 | $7.00 |
| FY2026 | $7.00 |
Shares outstanding
Share count rose 2% over 9 years
Show as table
| Year | Shares outstanding |
|---|---|
| FY2017 | 24M |
| FY2018 | 24M |
| FY2019 | 24M |
| FY2020 | 24M |
| FY2021 | 24M |
| FY2022 | 24M |
| FY2023 | 24M |
| FY2024 | 24M |
| FY2025 | 24M |
| FY2026 | 24M |
Delayed quote
Delayed price and chart from TradingView. This site does not receive or store these prices, and the fair value above does not use them. Showing the chart sends TradingView this page's address, the widget type, the ticker and your IP address, and TradingView may collect analytics; see Privacy.
Sources. Company figures: SEC EDGAR (XBRL filings), latest filing used 2026-11-06. Interest rate: U.S. Treasury, 10-year par yield, 2026-11-13.