← All stocks

American Financial Group Inc

AFGInsuranceLatest filing used: 2026-11-05Filings on SEC EDGAR ↗

Above fair value Strong balance sheet Dividend grower

Fair value per share

$77.71

from SEC filings only

Last close

$161.04

Nov 13, 2026

107.2% above fair value

Margin of safety price
$58.28
25% below fair value
Stress case
$60.14
if things go badly

Its filings point to about $77.71 a share, most likely between $63.81 and $83.45.

Where it sits

280 of the 653 stocks we value that have a close are even further above their estimates.

Counts the 653 stocks that have both a value and a close as of Nov 13. Positions are squeezed so the biggest gaps fit.

The short case

In favour

  • Sales have grown about 7% a year over the last five years.
  • It earns high returns on the money invested in it.
  • Its debt is modest next to its equity.

Against

  • Its last close is about 107% above what its filings say it is worth.

Written automatically from the filings, by the same rules for every company. Not a recommendation.

Price tags

The last close next to our fair value, the filings-based estimate above. Profit and cash flow: the 12 months to September 30, 2026.

MeasureAt last close$161.04Nov 13At our fair value$77.71
Market valueAll 83 million shares at that price (the diluted count, which includes stock options and awards)$13.4B$6.4B
Price / earnings (P/E)Dollars paid for each $1 of yearly profit13.1×6.3×

Price / free cash flow and EV / EBITDA are not used for most financial companies, such as banks, brokers, exchanges and insurers.

Our own arithmetic on the filings, the last close and our fair value, which is an estimate. One unusual year can push any of these very high or very low. How we work these out

Five areas

19 of 25 checks passedStrong in 4 of 5 areas

GrowthStrong · 4 of 5
  • Revenue up 5%+ a year over 3 years (passed)
  • Revenue up 5%+ a year over 5 years (passed)
  • Earnings per share up 5%+ a year over 5 years (not passed)
  • Revenue up over the last 12 months (passed)
  • Earnings per share up over the last 12 months (passed)
ProfitabilityStrong · 5 of 5
  • Return on equity of 15%+ (last 12 months) (passed)
  • Return on equity of 12%+ (5-year average) (passed)
  • Return on invested capital of 10%+ (5-year average) (passed)
  • Operating margin of 10%+ (5-year average) (passed)
  • Operating margin holding up (last 12 months vs 5 years) (passed)
Cash generationWeak · 1 of 5
  • Cash earnings positive in almost every year (at most one bad year) (no data)
  • Typical year turns 10%+ of revenue into cash (no data)
  • Latest year at or above the typical year (no data)
  • Free cash flow positive (last 12 months) (no data)
  • Revenue larger than 5 years ago (passed)
Balance sheetStrong · 4 of 5
  • Debt no larger than equity (passed)
  • Cash and short-term investments exceed debt (no data)
  • Positive shareholders' equity (passed)
  • Debt clearly tagged in the filings (passed)
  • Operating margin above zero (last 12 months) (passed)
Shareholder returnsStrong · 5 of 5
  • Pays a dividend (passed)
  • Dividend paid in each of the last 5 years (passed)
  • Dividend grew over 5 years (passed)
  • Pays out 75% or less of earnings (passed)
  • Share count flat or falling over 5 years (passed)

Flags

No flags raised in the latest filing.

How we got this number

AFG earned a typical 19.0% a year on its book value of $57.12 a share. We let that return fade to the 10.2% investors require over ten years. That is worth $77.71 a share today.

Technical details
Model
Residual income (book value and return on equity)
Book value per share
$57.12
Return on equity: typical year (worst 3-year stretch)
19.0% (12.5%)
Required return
10.2%
Value if investors require Treasury + 3 / + 8 points (we use + 5)
$84.11 / $69.48
Likely range
10th–90th percentile of 4,000 runs with different assumptions
Required return
10-year Treasury 5.15% (2026-11-13) + 5%

Ten years of results

Revenue

$8.2B in FY2025, down 2% on the year before

FY2016: $6.5BFY2017: $6.9BFY2018: $7.2BFY2019: $6.2BFY2020: $5.8BFY2021: $6.6BFY2022: $7.0BFY2023: $7.8BFY2024: $8.3BFY2025: $8.2B$5B$10BFY16FY19FY22FY25$8.2B
Show as table
YearRevenue
FY2016$6.5B
FY2017$6.9B
FY2018$7.2B
FY2019$6.2B
FY2020$5.8B
FY2021$6.6B
FY2022$7.0B
FY2023$7.8B
FY2024$8.3B
FY2025$8.2B

Dividends per share

$7.28 a share in FY2025

FY2016: $2.15FY2017: $4.79FY2018: $4.45FY2019: $4.95FY2020: $3.85FY2021: $28.06FY2022: $14.31FY2023: $8.10FY2024: $9.43FY2025: $7.28$15$30FY16FY19FY22FY25$7.28
Show as table
YearDividends per share
FY2016$2.15
FY2017$4.79
FY2018$4.45
FY2019$4.95
FY2020$3.85
FY2021$28.06
FY2022$14.31
FY2023$8.10
FY2024$9.43
FY2025$7.28

Shares outstanding

Share count fell 6% over 9 years

FY2016: 88MFY2017: 90MFY2018: 91MFY2019: 91MFY2020: 89MFY2021: 86MFY2022: 85MFY2023: 85MFY2024: 84MFY2025: 84M050M100MFY16FY19FY22FY2583.5M
Show as table
YearShares outstanding
FY201688M
FY201790M
FY201891M
FY201991M
FY202089M
FY202186M
FY202285M
FY202385M
FY202484M
FY202584M

No cash earnings in the filings.

Delayed quote

Delayed price and chart from TradingView. This site does not receive or store these prices, and the fair value above does not use them. Showing the chart sends TradingView this page's address, the widget type, the ticker and your IP address, and TradingView may collect analytics; see Privacy.

Open on Yahoo Finance ↗

Sources. Company figures: SEC EDGAR (XBRL filings), latest filing used 2026-11-05. Interest rate: U.S. Treasury, 10-year par yield, 2026-11-13. Last close: IEX Historical Data, 2026-11-13. Price tags: our own arithmetic on the SEC figures, the last close and our fair value.